
Why Molly McClure thinks drug testing should fit the job
Molly McClure is a Fractional Chief Marketing Officer at DrugScreens.com, a national e-commerce supplier of rapid drug testing kits. McClure argues that employers should consider the job, local rules and purpose of a test instead of assuming more panels or a one-size-fits-all policy is better.
McClure believes employers should start with what they need a drug testing policy to accomplish, then choose tests that fit the role and regulatory context. Helping customers make an informed choice can matter more than selling them a larger purchase.
What’s one opinion about your industry that most of your peers would disagree with?
I think too many organizations take a one-size-fits-all approach to drug testing.
That’s a slightly awkward thing to say when you co-own a company that sells drug tests, isn’t it?
But there’s a big difference between someone operating a 40-ton crane on a construction site and a financial analyst building spreadsheets at a corporate office. Why should we automatically assume they need the same drug testing policy?
Safety-sensitive industries have very real risks and, in many cases, strict regulatory requirements. I absolutely support that. But in other professions, employers may need to rethink what they’re screening for and why.
Take marijuana. Someone could legally consume cannabis on a Saturday evening and test positive on a Tuesday morning. That result alone doesn’t tell you whether they’re impaired at work or capable of doing their job safely.
Somewhere along the way, more testing became synonymous with better testing. I disagree.
A 16-panel drug test isn’t inherently better than a 5-panel drug test, just as ordering everything on a restaurant menu doesn’t guarantee a better dinner.
I’d argue that the smartest employers aren’t necessarily testing for more substances. They’re being more intentional about what they test for, who they test and why.
What convinced you? Tell us about the moment, client or result that changed your mind.
One particular court ruling really drove this home for me: Sanders v. Levari, a New Jersey appellate court case involving marijuana testing and employment protections.
At DrugScreens.com, we’ve built an AI-powered news monitoring system that alerts us to changes in drug testing legislation and court rulings in near real time. The New Jersey case was a particularly interesting example of how a seemingly routine hiring practice can become a legal headache.
Think about it. A company could have offices in Texas, California and New Jersey, purchase identical drug testing kits for all three locations, and face very different legal considerations when acting on those results.
Same company. Same test. Different rules.
That’s fascinating to me as both a business owner and a marketer. It also made me realize that our responsibility extends beyond simply selling drug tests. We need to help customers understand the changing environment in which they’re using them.
Since introducing our real-time industry news initiative, we’ve seen an approximately 15% increase in sales. There’s a certain irony in growing a drug testing business by encouraging people to rethink their drug testing practices.
But I think it speaks to something bigger: customers value businesses that help them make better decisions, not just bigger purchases.
What’s the usual way people in your field handle this, and what do you do instead?
Our industry tends to be very transactional. How many panels do you want? How many boxes do you need? What’s your budget?
We like to start with a different question: What are you actually trying to accomplish?
A university researcher studying substance use, a construction company concerned about workplace safety and a sober living facility supporting someone’s recovery are three very different customers. Why would we approach them the same way?
Take cannabis, for example. Recreational marijuana is now legal in 24 states and Washington, D.C. At DrugScreens.com, we made a conscious business decision to offer an entire collection of drug tests without THC. We’re not advocating that every employer stop testing for marijuana. We’re recognizing that the market has changed and giving employers options that reflect their evolving policies, safety needs and regulatory obligations.
We also spend a considerable amount of time educating customers about everything from changing state laws to emerging substances and alternative testing methods.
It’s a bit unconventional for an e-commerce business. Most retailers want to get you from the homepage to the checkout as quickly as possible. Sometimes, we actually want customers to slow down.
I’d much rather have a customer purchase a less expensive test that meets their needs than a more expensive one that doesn’t.
That’s not necessarily great for today’s shopping cart, but it’s a pretty good strategy for building a business that people trust and come back to.
Where has this view cost you, or where have you had to admit you were partly wrong?
The biggest cost has been time. There are certainly easier ways to run an e-commerce business than keeping up with legislation across 50 states, reading court rulings and monitoring emerging substances. Believe me, appellate court decisions aren’t exactly light bedtime reading!
I’ve also had to remind myself that just because something is changing doesn’t mean everyone needs to change with it.
I’m a marketer by background, so I naturally get excited about challenging conventional thinking. But sometimes a traditional 5-panel urine test is exactly what a customer needs. There’s no reason to complicate it.
I’ve learned that there’s a difference between being innovative and chasing innovation for the sake of it. Our job isn’t to convince customers to abandon what’s working. It’s to make sure they know their options when their needs change.
Not everything needs disrupting. And coming from a marketer, that’s probably another unpopular opinion.
What should someone in your field stop doing, and what should they start doing?
Stop assuming that what worked ten years ago is still the best approach today. Start getting curious.
The world is changing. Marijuana laws are evolving, new substances are emerging, and employers are navigating an increasingly complicated regulatory landscape. Yet it’s surprisingly easy to fall into the trap of doing something simply because that’s how it’s always been done.
I’d also encourage business owners to become students of their industry, not just sellers within it. Some of our most valuable marketing insights haven’t come from marketing publications. They’ve come from court rulings, legislative developments and conversations with customers.
And don’t be afraid to challenge conventional thinking, even when it seems counterintuitive to your own business model. There’s something powerful about telling a customer they might not need everything you’re selling.
You might sacrifice a little revenue today, but you could earn a customer for the next ten years.
After all, we sell drug tests, but what our customers are ultimately buying is confidence.
Thank you to Molly McClure and the team at DrugScreens.com for sharing an honest view with Leaders Perception readers.
Have a view your industry needs to hear?
Leaders Perception publishes interviews with business owners and leaders who see their industry differently. Five questions, about ten minutes, no calls. It is free and every completed interview gets published.
