Why John W. Ament says there is no single AI ranking to win

John W. Ament, Owner and Founder at BeAIOptimized
The Unpopular Opinion

Why John W. Ament says there is no single AI ranking to win

John W. Ament is the owner and founder of BeAIOptimized, which tests how five leading AI assistants recommend local businesses, publishes the findings and offers business owners custom reports. Ament explains why chasing one assistant’s top spot can be misleading, and what businesses can check instead.

John W. AmentOwner and Founder at BeAIOptimized
Published November 22, 2026
The takeaway

Ament’s tests suggest there is no single, stable AI ranking for local businesses to win. A more useful approach, in Ament’s view, is to check multiple assistants, repeat the questions and review the public sources they rely on.

01

What’s one opinion about your industry that most of your peers would disagree with?

Much of the AI search industry talks about "ranking number one in ChatGPT," and I think that framing is wrong. There is no single AI ranking to win. Different assistants give different answers to the same question, so a business that chases one assistant’s top spot is working toward something that barely exists.

We tested this. In November 2026 we asked ChatGPT, Gemini, Grok, Claude and Perplexity 400 local-service questions, 2,000 answers in total, and published the results in our study, State of AI Recommendations for Local Businesses. About two in three of the businesses named for a question (4,346 of 6,468) were named by only one of the five assistants. Only 103 of those 6,468 names, or 2%, were named by all five. ChatGPT named 4.0 businesses per answer on average, and Perplexity named 2.5. If there were one list to win, those numbers would look very different.

The study is here: https://beaioptimized.com/guides/ai-recommendations-local-business-study/

02

What convinced you? Tell us about the moment, client or result that changed your mind.

What convinced me was the testing itself. In late October 2026 we asked ChatGPT and Perplexity the same local-service questions in 40 U.S. cities, three times each, and got 960 usable answers. For the same question in the same city, they gave the same top pick only 9% of the time. In 63% of cases, their lists had no business in common at all.

That was the moment I stopped believing "get ranked in ChatGPT" was a real goal. We then ran a larger test in November with all 5 leading AIs (ChatGPT, Gemini, Grok, Claude and Perplexity): 400 questions and 2,000 answers. The same pattern showed up, only clearer: 4,346 of 6,468 businesses named for a question came from just one of the five. Only 2% were named by all five.

Once I had those counts, I couldn’t promise anyone a single ranking. The results are public in our study, State of AI Recommendations for Local Businesses, last updated November 17, 2026.

03

What’s the usual way people in your field handle this, and what do you do instead?

The usual way in this field is to talk about winning a ranking in one assistant, often ChatGPT, as if that were the whole job, and to wrap the result into one number.

I don’t do that, because the tests don’t support it. Instead, I check what each of the 5 leading AIs actually says, and which websites it leans on. In our November study, 1,439 of 2,000 answers (72%) listed a review or directory site among their sources, 1,497 (75%) listed a business or brand website, and 1,296 (65%) mentioned reviews. That tells me consistent public facts matter more than any one assistant’s list.

I also ask each question more than once, because the answer can change. Then I report what we actually counted, including where the five assistants disagree. For a local business owner, that is more useful than a promise nobody can keep.

04

Where has this view cost you, or where have you had to admit you were partly wrong?

This view has cost me in a simple way: it is a harder sell. A business owner would rather hear that we can get them to the top of one list. I won’t say that, because our tests show that list barely exists. So I give up a cleaner sales story.

I also had to admit I was partly wrong about how stable any one check is. In our October test of 960 answers, we asked every question three times. ChatGPT gave the same top pick all three times for only 6% of questions, and Perplexity for 25%. Even the assistant you checked today may name someone else tomorrow. That is why, when we test a business, we ask each question twice and still treat the result as a snapshot, not a final verdict.

05

What should someone in your field stop doing, and what should they start doing?

People in this field should stop promising that a business can "rank number one in ChatGPT," and stop treating one check of one assistant as the truth. They should also stop talking as if the five assistants share one list. In our November study, only 103 of 6,468 businesses named for a question, or 2%, were named by all 5 leading AIs.

What they should start doing follows from the counts. Test more than one assistant. We use ChatGPT, Gemini, Grok, Claude and Perplexity. Ask the question more than once. Then look at the sources, not just the names. In 2,000 answers, 72% listed a review or directory site, 75% listed a business or brand website, and 65% mentioned reviews. A good first step for any local business is to make sure its name, phone number, address and other public facts match on its own site and on those listings.

The goal isn’t to win a ranking that isn’t there. The goal is to be one of the names the assistants actually give.

Thank you to John W. Ament and the team at BeAIOptimized for sharing an honest view with Leaders Perception readers.

Share this interview

Have a view your industry needs to hear?

Leaders Perception publishes interviews with business owners and leaders who see their industry differently. Five questions, about ten minutes, no calls. It is free and every completed interview gets published.

Get featured on Leaders Perception

Explore additional categories

Explore Other Interviews