
Why Conor Smart tests AI tools before adding another subscription
Conor Smart is Founder and Managing Director of Arklavo, which makes custom team uniforms and branded workwear for businesses in many countries. Smart argues marketers should test new AI tools against features they already pay for, and explains how Arklavo evaluates subscriptions and checks AI-generated changes before publication.
Smart recommends testing a new AI tool against existing platforms before paying for it, then checking its work on a small sample before making changes live. His experience suggests both subscription decisions and AI-generated updates need careful review.
What’s one opinion about your industry that most of your peers would disagree with?
I’d say that in most cases, the extra AI content or ads tool isn’t worth the extra subscription. Marketers love to pile on AI content and ads tools because they offer something shiny and new, like better ad copy, better targeting, better bids, better reporting, etc. I’m all for testing these tools to see if they outperform what’s currently offered by Meta, Shopify or Google, but in many cases I find they’re basically offering the same thing that’s already being offered natively in the product.
What convinced you? Tell us about the moment, client or result that changed your mind.
Honestly, it wasn’t one particular client or project. I used to jump on every new AI ads tool or AI content tool as soon as they were announced, thinking if I didn’t adopt them quickly we’d fall behind. We ended up wasting money because in many cases these tools offered features we were already paying for in Google or Meta or Shopify. We’d get no better performance using the new AI tool than we did using our existing products, but we still had to pay for the new tool, onboard our team to learn how to use it, log in somewhere new, etc.
What’s the usual way people in your field handle this, and what do you do instead?
I’ve noticed in marketing in general that as soon as a new tool is announced, people jump on board right away. They watch a demo video, try the trial version, and soon after that their business is paying for the product. In many cases, this results in redundant products because the new tool is basically doing the same thing as another product they’re using. Instead of jumping on every new product right away, I like to put the new product up against the current product we’re using to see if it truly outperforms. I also like to shop around and see what else is out there before jumping on a product. For example, before we found our favorite product customizer app, we tried a few others to see which one would work best for us.
This approach has worked really well for us because we’re able to make sure that we’re getting the best bang for our buck. For example, we audit our apps and software subscriptions and get rid of the ones we don’t use. On the flip side, there are tools we use religiously because we know they provide value, for example, we’ve been using Claude for a year now to help automate tasks and workflows, create content, build agents, etc. because we know it does these things exceptionally well and efficiently.
Where has this view cost you, or where have you had to admit you were partly wrong?
I guess in some cases I’ve trusted certain tools a tad bit too much. For example, I once let Claude make updates to products on our website and it made incorrect updates that we then had to go in and fix manually, which took weeks. I still stand by my initial assertion, which is that you shouldn’t sign up for a new AI tool unless it provides value above and beyond what you’re already getting, but I do now put AI-generated changes through more of a vetting process before they go live on our site.
Specifically, rather than letting an AI update all of our products or content at once, we now test out its suggestions on a few items first, we make sure our instructions to the AI are very clear, and then we vet the changes before publishing them. AI can be your best friend or worst enemy depending on how you use it.
What should someone in your field stop doing, and what should they start doing?
If there’s one thing I’d advise other marketers it would be this: don’t jump on board with a new AI tool right away just because it was announced. Use the trial period to put it through its paces and see if it truly offers anything above and beyond what you’re already paying for elsewhere (in Google, Meta, Shopify, etc). If it doesn’t, save your money. On the flip side, if you do decide to use an AI tool, make sure you’re providing it with clear instructions, test out its suggestions on a few items first rather than implementing them sitewide, and vet everything before you hit publish.
Thank you to Conor Smart and the team at Arklavo for sharing an honest view with Leaders Perception readers.
Have a view your industry needs to hear?
Leaders Perception publishes interviews with business owners and leaders who see their industry differently. Five questions, about ten minutes, no calls. It is free and every completed interview gets published.
