Why Spicer Matthews wants software to be easy to leave

Spicer Matthews, Founder at Harbor (Cloudmanic Labs)
The Unpopular Opinion

Why Spicer Matthews wants software to be easy to leave

Spicer Matthews is founder of Harbor (Cloudmanic Labs), a private notes app for storing notes, scans, documents and voice memos. After developing products on Evernote’s platform and using Evernote for 15 years, Spicer Matthews explains why software should make leaving easy, and how that belief shapes Harbor’s exports, cancellation policy and pricing.

Spicer MatthewsFounder at Harbor (Cloudmanic Labs)
Published November 21, 2026
The takeaway

Retention should come from a product customers choose to keep, not friction that makes leaving difficult. Harbor applies that principle through open-format exports, read-only access after cancellation and a written price commitment, while accepting the trade-off in pricing flexibility.

01

What’s one opinion about your industry that most of your peers would disagree with?

Software companies should make it easy for customers to leave.

A lot of subscription software treats switching costs as a moat. Make export painful, make canceling a chore, and once someone is years deep, raise the price. They’re not going anywhere.

I think that’s backwards. If the only thing keeping a customer is that leaving is hard, you don’t have a loyal customer. You have a captive one, and they’ll leave the first day it gets easier.

02

What convinced you? Tell us about the moment, client or result that changed your mind.

Evernote, twice.

The first time, I was a developer. Cloudmanic built three products on Evernote’s platform. We talked to their team before we started and were told we’d be partners. Months of work and tens of thousands of dollars later, we learned what everyone building on someone else’s platform learns. You’re not in charge. They are. Two of those three products ended up in the bin.

The second time, I was a customer. I kept my life in Evernote for 15 years: contracts, receipts, my kids’ drawings, meeting recordings. After it was sold, the Personal plan went from $69.99 a year to $129.99. Then the plans were renamed, and the one that holds an unlimited library is now $249.99.

I kept paying anyway. Not because the product was getting better, but because leaving meant moving 15 years of my life. That isn’t loyalty. It’s gravity. Once I saw it that way, I wanted to build the opposite.

03

What’s the usual way people in your field handle this, and what do you do instead?

The usual way: export exists, but it’s buried, slow, or in a format nothing else reads. Prices are "subject to change," and the people with the most to lose are the ones who feel it.

At Harbor we went the other way:

– Full export on every plan, anytime, in open formats (ENEX, HTML, ZIP), plus a complete account export. – Stop paying and your account goes read-only and free, not dark. You can still read, export, and delete everything. – The price is in writing. $9.99 a month or $99 a year, no increase for your first three years, then never more than 10% a year. – Every new account starts with a copy of that promise as a note, dated the day you joined. If we ever break it, the evidence is already sitting in your own library.

The door out is as wide as the door in. Moving from Evernote is one step.

It’s working. Paying customers have grown more than 60% a month since we launched on August 1, and one App Store review calls out the price guarantee by name.

04

Where has this view cost you, or where have you had to admit you were partly wrong?

It costs us pricing power, and I’ve argued the other side in public.

In January I wrote that a small software company is better off with 100 customers at $200 a month than 1,000 at $20. Charge more, need fewer people. Then I launched Harbor at $9.99 a month and promised in writing that your price won’t go up for three years. If I priced it too low, everyone who has already subscribed keeps that price anyway. The usual fix, raising it on the people who are already in, is exactly the move I promised never to make. Those two ideas pull against each other, and I picked the promise.

It costs us customers, too, on purpose. We built a free tool that converts an Evernote export to Markdown, right in your browser, with no account and no upload. It’s for anyone leaving Evernote, including people headed to Obsidian or a plain folder of files instead of Harbor. The post announcing it tells those people to go use it.

I’d make both trades again. A promise that only holds when it’s cheap isn’t a promise.

05

What should someone in your field stop doing, and what should they start doing?

Stop treating switching costs as a moat. If your retention depends on export being painful, you have a product problem, and you’re hiding it from yourself.

Stop writing "prices subject to change." Your customers read that as "we’ll raise it once you’re stuck."

Start putting your pricing promise in writing, dated, somewhere the customer keeps a copy.

Start testing export as hard as you test import, and make it produce something a competitor can read. If someone could leave you in an afternoon and still stays, that’s the only retention number worth bragging about.

Thank you to Spicer Matthews and the team at Harbor (Cloudmanic Labs) for sharing an honest view with Leaders Perception readers.

Share this interview

Have a view your industry needs to hear?

Leaders Perception publishes interviews with business owners and leaders who see their industry differently. Five questions, about ten minutes, no calls. It is free and every completed interview gets published.

Get featured on Leaders Perception

Explore additional categories

Explore Other Interviews