
Why Nick Brennan thinks sexual health publishing needs more context
Nick Brennan is Founder & Editor of Signal & Response, an independent digital publication focused on men’s sexual health and sexuality. Brennan argues publishers should explain when health advice applies rather than turn complex experiences into universal answers, and reflects on the commercial and editorial tradeoffs of that approach.
Sexual health publishers can offer clear advice without presenting it as universal: explain the context, evidence and limits that shape an answer. Brennan also argues that nuance should not make readers work too hard to find the point.
What’s one opinion about your industry that most of your peers would disagree with?
I think publishers are far too comfortable offering definitive, one-size-fits-all answers to questions that rarely have them.
Whether it’s advice about health, relationships, sexuality, or what men and women supposedly want, complicated subjects are frequently reduced to sweeping generalizations. There’s a commercial incentive for doing so. Bold, definitive statements tend to attract attention, generate engagement, and are often easier to turn into product recommendations or sales opportunities. But what’s good for a publisher’s bottom line isn’t necessarily what’s good for its audience. Even an answer that’s technically accurate can be misleading without the appropriate context.
I believe publishers should spend less time positioning themselves as authorities with all the answers and more time helping readers understand when those answers apply, where their limitations are, and how to evaluate the information for themselves.
What convinced you? Tell us about the moment, client or result that changed your mind.
The more time I spent researching and writing about men’s sexual health, the more I noticed how easily ordinary experiences were being framed as problems that needed fixing.
Take something as common as losing an erection during sex. It’s easy to frame that experience as a sign of erectile dysfunction. But whether it happens occasionally, only in certain situations, or consistently over time can completely change what it means. Sometimes there’s a legitimate medical issue worth investigating. Other times, there may be nothing wrong at all.
That realization helped shape the direction of Signal & Response. The publication was originally much more focused on sexual health challenges, but I wanted to explore sexuality more broadly, including desire, pleasure, relationships, and sexual expectations. When we overhauled the publication, we made those subjects a much bigger part of our editorial focus because there’s far more to understanding human sexuality than identifying and treating problems.
The experience reinforced something I’d come to believe about digital publishing more generally: when we focus too heavily on providing answers and solutions, we often lose sight of the context that makes those answers useful in the first place.
What’s the usual way people in your field handle this, and what do you do instead?
A lot of sexual health content, especially on social media, follows a familiar formula: take something people may already feel insecure about, frame it as a problem, and offer a simple solution. Sometimes that’s a supplement or treatment conveniently available through an affiliate link. Other times it’s definitive advice about how men should behave, what makes someone masculine, or what women supposedly want.
Both approaches rely on a level of certainty that isn’t always justified. An occasional erection problem doesn’t automatically mean a man needs treatment, and no article or influencer can tell you what every woman wants. People are different, circumstances matter, and the answers aren’t always the same.
I’m not opposed to affiliate marketing, practical advice, or clear conclusions. Signal & Response is an independent men’s sexual health publication, and we use affiliate links, too. But I don’t think publishers should manufacture problems to sell solutions or present sweeping generalizations as universal truths.
At Signal & Response, we start with the experience someone is trying to understand, look at what the research actually supports, and explain which details might change the answer. Sometimes a treatment genuinely makes sense. Other times, there’s nothing that needs fixing. And sometimes the most useful advice is to stop guessing what your partner wants and ask them.
Where has this view cost you, or where have you had to admit you were partly wrong?
There’s a real commercial tradeoff to the approach we’re taking at Signal & Response. Fear and insecurity can be incredibly effective at driving attention, particularly on social media, and there’s no shortage of products promising to solve whatever problem someone has been convinced they have. We have affiliate relationships ourselves, but we don’t treat every discussion of a treatment, device, or supplement as an opportunity to sell something. We also avoid headlines and social content designed to make people worry unnecessarily about their health or sexual performance.
The challenge is that we’re still trying to build a successful publication. We need traffic, engagement, and revenue to make that possible. We’re just trying to accomplish those things without compromising the editorial philosophy that makes Signal & Response different.
I’ve also learned that providing more context isn’t automatically better. There have been times when I’ve gotten so caught up in explaining every possible variable or limitation that the actual point becomes difficult to follow. If someone has to work through five paragraphs of caveats before getting to the answer, I haven’t necessarily served them any better.
That’s probably the biggest lesson for me. Accuracy and nuance matter, but so does respecting the reader’s time. Finding the right balance is something I’m still working on as the publication grows.
What should someone in your field stop doing, and what should they start doing?
Stop writing headlines that promise more certainty than the evidence can support. Stop treating every question, concern, or personal experience as a problem that needs to be solved. And stop treating men and women as monoliths.
Start giving readers enough context to understand when an answer applies, where its limitations are, and what circumstances might change it. And acknowledge when there simply isn’t one answer that applies to everyone.
None of that requires making content unnecessarily complicated. Clear writing and careful writing aren’t mutually exclusive. I think publishers owe their audiences both.
Thank you to Nick Brennan and the team at Signal & Response for sharing an honest view with Leaders Perception readers.
Have a view your industry needs to hear?
Leaders Perception publishes interviews with business owners and leaders who see their industry differently. Five questions, about ten minutes, no calls. It is free and every completed interview gets published.
