Amy Castello: domain authority is a weak reason to buy

Amy Castello, Founder at Adbassador
The Unpopular Opinion

Amy Castello: domain authority is a weak reason to buy

Amy Castello is the founder of Adbassador, a vetted marketplace where advertisers buy guest posts, link insertions, banner ads and press releases from publishers. Castello argues that domain authority alone is a poor basis for buying a sponsored post, and explains how buyers can check a site’s other metrics, traffic and content.

Amy CastelloFounder at Adbassador
Published November 19, 2026
The takeaway

Treat domain authority as one signal, not a ranking or a reason to buy on its own. Cross-check it against other tools, the site’s traffic and its content, while recognizing that Adbassador’s order data does not prove that mid-range sites outperform higher-authority ones.

01

What’s one opinion about your industry that most of your peers would disagree with?

A high domain authority score is a weak reason to buy a sponsored post. Most buyers in our industry sort a list by DA and only then look at price, and I think that order is backwards. DA tells you how much link equity a domain has accumulated. It does not tell you whether anyone reads the site or trusts it.

02

What convinced you? Tell us about the moment, client or result that changed your mind.

It was the order history on our own marketplace. We list close to 900 placements with their metrics shown, so buyers choose with full information. When I sorted every listing by DA band and counted orders, the top of the range was narrow. We have 19 live listings at DA 70 or above and very few orders have been placed. Buyers who can see the number and pick freely are not paying for the highest one.

03

What’s the usual way people in your field handle this, and what do you do instead?

The usual way is to treat DA as a ranking: set a minimum, then buy the cheapest site above it. What I do instead is read DA alongside the other signals. I check that Ahrefs DR and Semrush AS roughly agree with it, that the site has real organic traffic, and that the content on the pages around where the link would go matches the topic. If the metrics disagree with each other, that is the finding. We turned down a health blog this week for exactly that reason: a DA of 37 sitting next to a DR of 0, and gambling spam in its trending posts.

04

Where has this view cost you, or where have you had to admit you were partly wrong?

DA is not useless, and I overreach when I say it is. It is a decent filter for junk: sites with a DA near zero and a spam score to match are rarely worth it. I also can’t claim that mid-range sites win. Most of our order volume comes through a single publisher, so the data cannot separate "mid-range DA sells" from "one good seller sells". Being honest about that has cost me some neat talking points.

05

What should someone in your field stop doing, and what should they start doing?

Stop buying on a single number, and stop trusting a metric just because the vendor quoted it. Start cross-checking two or three tools against each other, looking at where the site’s traffic actually comes from, and reading the site itself before paying. A thirty-second look at the homepage would have caught the gambling links I mentioned above.

Thank you to Amy Castello and the team at Adbassador for sharing an honest view with Leaders Perception readers.

Share this interview

Have a view your industry needs to hear?

Leaders Perception publishes interviews with business owners and leaders who see their industry differently. Five questions, about ten minutes, no calls. It is free and every completed interview gets published.

Get featured on Leaders Perception

Explore additional categories

Explore Other Interviews