How Brooke Meisenzahl turned a loose tooth into a business

BM
Behind the Business

How Brooke Meisenzahl turned a loose tooth into a business

Brooke Meisenzahl launched Tooth Fairy Flylight in 2023 after turning her daughter’s questions about a loose tooth into a story-led product for families. The conversation explores how she explains a new idea to customers, navigated safety testing and manufacturing, and built a business around making a childhood tradition easier for parents to share.

Brooke MeisenzahlFounder at Tooth Fairy Flylight
Published November 18, 2026
The takeaway

A small business does not have to do everything or grow as quickly as possible. Focus on the few things that matter most, and seek help from people with expertise you lack.

01

What’s the short story of how your business started, and what makes it genuinely different from the other options your customers have?

Tooth Fairy Flylight started with my daughter’s first loose tooth and about a million questions about the Tooth Fairy. Where does she live? How does she know when to come? What does she do with all those teeth?

I wanted to make this milestone feel as magical as my daughter imagined it could be, but everything I found was either too generic or required more crafting skills and time than I had! So I started writing little letters back and forth between my daughter and the Tooth Fairy. Before long, we’d created a whole magical world together.

That experience became the inspiration for Tooth Fairy Flylight, which I launched in 2023.

What makes us different is that we don’t just give kids a place to leave their tooth. We give them a way to become part of the magic. Our storybook introduces children to a world of tooth fairies, including one they get to name themselves. And our Flylight is a magical nightlight that lets them send a signal to call their very own fairy.

I love that we’re taking a tradition families already cherish and giving children a bigger role in it. Instead of just believing in the magic, they get to help make it happen.

02

How did you win your first customers, and where does most of your new business come from today?

One thing I learned pretty quickly is that when you’re introducing a completely new idea, you have to do more than show people a product. You have to help them understand the experience.

I came into this with a marketing background, so I knew we needed to reach families in different ways, from social media and digital advertising to PR, influencers, and word of mouth. But getting those pieces to work together, especially with the limited resources of a small business, has been a learning experience.

Today, we sell through our website and Amazon, and we’re continuing to build awareness through partnerships, media coverage, and families sharing their experiences.

One of my favorite things is introducing the Flylight to children in person. When they learn that there’s a tooth fairy just for them, and that they can actually send her a signal, their faces light up. Those moments remind me that we’re not just selling a product. We’re introducing families to a whole new way to experience a tradition they already love.

03

What’s one decision that changed the direction of your business, and one mistake that taught you the most?

One of my biggest decisions was to think beyond the original Flylight boxed set and start building a larger brand around the Tooth Fairy tradition.

It was a little scary because we’re a bootstrapped business, and developing physical products takes time and money. But I realized that what I’d created wasn’t just a nightlight and a book. It was a whole world with more stories to tell and more ways for children to experience the magic. That led us to expand our collection, including Tugs the Tooth, our little tooth pillow companion.

As for mistakes, I think I underestimated just how much I didn’t know about bringing a physical product to market! I had a background in marketing and storytelling, but manufacturing, safety testing, and product development were entirely new territory.

At one point, just getting connected with the right safety testing company delayed our manufacturing process by six to eight months. I spent an incredible amount of time trying to figure everything out myself.

That experience taught me to be persistent, but also to recognize when I need help. You don’t have to know how to do everything. You do have to be willing to ask questions, find the right people, and keep going when the answer isn’t immediately obvious.

04

What has changed in your industry or in what your customers expect over the last couple of years, and how have you adapted?

One thing I’ve become increasingly aware of is how much parents want to create meaningful experiences for their children, but how little time and energy they often have to make those experiences happen.

I can relate! I’m a mom of two, and I know how easy it is to have wonderful intentions but get caught up in the busyness of everyday life.

I also think there’s something especially meaningful about the ages when children begin losing their teeth. They’re becoming more independent, asking bigger questions, and figuring out how the world works. But they still believe in magic with their whole hearts.

That’s what I love about Tooth Fairy Flylight. It gives children a sense of independence and ownership over the experience, while making it easy for parents to participate.

We’ve continued to think about both sides of that equation as we’ve grown. The Flylight lets kids send their own signal, but it also has a built-in tooth tray so parents aren’t digging under pillows in the dark. The light turns itself off after an hour, and the tradition can begin with the first loose tooth, not just the night a tooth falls out.

For me, it’s about finding ways to make childhood feel a little more magical without making parenting more complicated.

05

If you were advising someone starting out in your industry today, what would you tell them to do first, and what would you tell them to ignore?

First, I’d tell them to make sure they’re solving a problem or creating something people genuinely care about. And then talk to people! Share your idea, ask questions, and be open to hearing things you might not expect.

I’d also tell them to find people who know what they don’t. When I started, I knew a lot about marketing and storytelling, but very little about manufacturing a children’s product. I had to learn about sourcing, safety testing, publishing, packaging, and a hundred other things I never anticipated. Finding people who were willing to share their expertise made an enormous difference.

As for what to ignore, I’d say the idea that you have to do everything, or that you have to grow as quickly as possible.

We’re still bootstrapping Tooth Fairy Flylight, and I’ve learned that there will always be more opportunities than time or resources. I try to focus on the three most important things I can do each day to move the business forward.

And I’d remind them to enjoy the little wins. I still get excited when a Flylight ships out the door. Something that started as an idea inspired by my daughter’s loose tooth is now becoming part of other families’ childhood memories. That’s pretty amazing.

Thank you to Brooke Meisenzahl and the team at Tooth Fairy Flylight for sharing what actually worked with Leaders Perception readers.

Share this interview

Want to tell the story behind your business?

Leaders Perception publishes interviews with business owners and leaders every week. Five questions, about ten minutes, no calls. It is free and every completed interview gets published.

Get featured on Leaders Perception

Explore additional categories

Explore Other Interviews