
Why Andrew Yu is wary of rentals for small investors
Andrew Yu is Founder and Real Estate Investor at Paranova Property Buyers, which buys problem or unwanted houses in Central Arkansas from homeowners who want to sell without making repairs or preparing a house for listing. This conversation looks at the costs that can reshape rental returns, and why Yu sometimes prefers selling with financing.
A rental’s monthly cash flow can look different after vacancies, turnovers, major repairs and the owner’s time are included. Yu recommends comparing the full costs and responsibilities of keeping a rental with selling outright or selling with financing.
What’s one opinion about your industry that most of your peers would disagree with?
I think rentals are a lousy investment for a lot of small investors. In my experience, a rental typically generates about $200 to $300 a month in net cash flow. At that pace, it takes a long time to get your original investment back, and one nightmare tenant can change the return on the whole deal. I have friends in the trades who think rentals are a great investment because they can do the repairs themselves. I get why that sounds appealing. But you still pay for materials, give up your time, and have to deal with whatever goes wrong. That costs you peace of mind, too.
What convinced you? Tell us about the moment, client or result that changed your mind.
Seeing what turnovers actually cost me changed my mind. I’ve spent $5,000 to $15,000 getting a house ready for the next tenant. At $200 to $300 a month, a $10,000 turnover can eat up roughly three to four years of cash flow from that house. And the big expenses can hit even with a good tenant. A sewer line can fail, the HVAC can go out, or the roof can need replacing. Any one of those is a big bill compared with what the house brings in each month.
What’s the usual way people in your field handle this, and what do you do instead?
A common approach is to buy a house, fix it up, and keep it as a rental. I prefer to sell with financing when the deal and the buyer are a good fit. I receive monthly payments, and under my agreement the buyer takes full responsibility for the house. If a pipe breaks, the HVAC goes out, or the roof needs replacing, the buyer arranges the work and pays for it. I don’t have to drop what I’m doing when something breaks, and I don’t have to budget for the next turnover.
Where has this view cost you, or where have you had to admit you were partly wrong?
When I sell, I give up any future appreciation on the house. I’m also counting on the buyer to keep making payments, so I have to be comfortable with the buyer and the terms. A rental with a reliable tenant and modest upkeep can work well. For some houses, I’m willing to give up the upside of continuing to own them because I know what it costs me in time, money, and peace of mind to keep them rented.
What should someone in your field stop doing, and what should they start doing?
Stop looking at a good month and assuming you’ll get twelve of them every year. Before you buy, run the numbers with a vacancy, a turnover, and money set aside for major expenses like plumbing, HVAC, and a roof. Ask how many months of cash flow it would take to recover from one big bill. Then ask who’s taking the calls, finding contractors, and getting the house ready for the next tenant. If that’s you, count your time too. Compare what you’d get from keeping the rental, selling outright, or selling with financing before you decide what to buy.
Thank you to Andrew Yu and the team at Paranova Property Buyers for sharing an honest view with Leaders Perception readers.
Have a view your industry needs to hear?
Leaders Perception publishes interviews with business owners and leaders who see their industry differently. Five questions, about ten minutes, no calls. It is free and every completed interview gets published.
