
Why Jeff Sullivan says retailers should stock beyond 2XL
Jeff Sullivan, owner and founder of Big Tall Jerseys, sells sports fan apparel in extended sizes, including men’s jerseys and apparel up to 6XL and 5XLT and women’s plus sizes up to 4X. Jeff Sullivan argues that treating big and tall as a small add-on misses the chance to earn repeat customers, but says loyalty only matters if shoppers can find the right product.
Build product pages around the sizes customers need, with clear information about what is available and how it fits. Jeff Sullivan’s experience also points to a practical condition: repeat loyalty cannot help if shoppers cannot find the product.
What’s one opinion about your industry that most of your peers would disagree with?
Most retailers treat big and tall like a charity case. A couple of 2XLs on the back rack and they call it done. I think that is backwards. The big guy is the most loyal customer in retail. When you finally sell him a jersey that actually fits in 6XL or 5XLT, he does not shop around. He comes back, and he tells every other big guy he knows where he got it.
What convinced you? Tell us about the moment, client or result that changed your mind.
Twenty-five years of watching it happen. I built my whole business on big and tall shoppers, and the pattern never changed. A guy spends years unable to find his size anywhere. Then he finds a jersey that fits, in his team, in 6XL or 5XLT. He buys it, he wears it, and he comes back for the next one. He brings his friends with him. No ad I have ever run has done what one happy big guy telling his buddies has done.
What’s the usual way people in your field handle this, and what do you do instead?
The usual way is to cap sizes at XL or 2XL and call the job done, because stocking the big sizes costs more inventory. The stores think they are saving money. What they are really doing is leaving their best customers on the table. What I do instead is build the whole shop around the sizes other stores skip. Every size listed out, one by one, up to 6XL and 5XLT for men and 4X for women, with plain guidance on how the sizes run. The page answers the exact question the shopper typed into Google: what fits, what sizes exist, what to buy for his team.
Where has this view cost you, or where have you had to admit you were partly wrong?
It cost me the easy path. Building size-led pages one team at a time is slow work, and I cannot carry everything the big stores carry. And I was partly wrong about loyalty being enough on its own. A loyal customer still has to find you first. That is the part I had to learn. The pages have to rank, and they only rank if they genuinely help the shopper who lands on them.
What should someone in your field stop doing, and what should they start doing?
Stop treating big and tall as an afterthought, and stop stopping at 2XL. Start listing your real size range on the product page, in plain words, and start writing for the shopper’s exact question instead of for the search engine. If you sell a man a jersey that fits, you do not have a one-time buyer. You have a customer for life.
Thank you to Jeff Sullivan and the team at Big Tall Jerseys for sharing an honest view with Leaders Perception readers.
Have a view your industry needs to hear?
Leaders Perception publishes interviews with business owners and leaders who see their industry differently. Five questions, about ten minutes, no calls. It is free and every completed interview gets published.
